Advice of Scholars - CHALLENGE

According to most ‘ulamâ’, though open tahaddî (challenge), that is, saying, “Go ahead and do the same! But you can’t!” is not a condition for a mu’jiza, the meaning of a mu’jiza contains tahaddî. Because a tahaddî is not a matter of question in the reports made about the states of the Rising Day and future events, these are not mu’jizas against disbelievers. Believers believe that these reports are mu’jizas. The karâmas of Awliyâ’ are not mu’jizas because they do not claim prophethood and because there is no tahaddî in them.